| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Depauw | 2-11 | on Depauw27 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Depauw | 2-11 | on Depauw27 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 6 yards to the DEPAUW33 (A. Pynenberg;Justin Gardiner). |
| | | Career-high rushing attempts for Marks |
| Depauw | 3-5 | on Depauw33 | Spud Dick rush for 1 yard to the DEPAUW34 (Jared Lange). |
| Depauw | 4-4 | on Depauw34 | Adam Hill punt 49 yards to the WAB17, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 2:27 |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab17 | WABASH COLLEGE drive start at 13:18. |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab17 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Brock Graham for 4 yards to the WAB21 (Ryan McElwain). |
| Wab | 2-6 | on Wab21 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Brock Graham for 12 yards to the WAB33, 1ST DOWN WAB (Jevon Pruitt). |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab33 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Mike Russell for 20 yards to the DEPAUW47, 1ST DOWN WAB, out-of-bounds. |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Depauw47 | Matt Hudson pass incomplete to Mike Russell, QB hurry by Alex Fitch. |
| Wab | 2-10 | on Depauw47 | Matt Hudson pass complete to C.P. Porter for 5 yards to the DEPAUW42 (Marc Hoeppner). |
| Wab | 3-5 | on Depauw42 | Matt Hudson pass incomplete to Mike Russell. |
| Wab | 4-5 | on Depauw42 | Chad Finley punt 25 yards to the DEPAUW17, out-of-bounds. |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 41 yards, TOP 2:22 |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw17 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 10:56. |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw17 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 19 yards to the DEPAUW36, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Thomas Bell;Rich Lehmann). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw36 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 2 yards to the DEPAUW38 (A. Pynenberg). |
| Depauw | 2-8 | on Depauw38 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 5 yards to the DEPAUW43 (Richard Roomes). |
| Depauw | 3-3 | on Depauw43 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 2 yards to the DEPAUW45 (Rich Lehmann). |
| Depauw | 4-1 | on Depauw45 | Spud Dick rush for 3 yards to the DEPAUW48, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Justin Gardiner). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw48 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 19 yards to the WAB33, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Richard Roomes;A. Pynenberg). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Wab33 | Spud Dick pass complete to Chris Gasbarra for 4 yards to the WAB29 (Thomas Bell). |
| Depauw | 2-6 | on Wab29 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 2 yards to the WAB27 (A. Pynenberg). |
| Depauw | 3-4 | on Wab27 | Spud Dick pass incomplete to Bryan Mulligan. |
| Depauw | 4-4 | on Wab27 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 5 yards to the WAB22, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Chad Peterman;Matt Kraft). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Wab22 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 4 yards to the WAB18 (Rich Lehmann;Chad Peterman). |
| Depauw | 2-6 | on Wab18 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 2 yards to the WAB16 (A. Pynenberg). |
| | | Marks breaks DePauw's 34-year-old single-game rushing attempt record |
| Depauw | 3-4 | on Wab16 | Spud Dick pass complete to Chris Gasbarra for 7 yards to the WAB9, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Thomas Bell). |
| Depauw | 1-G | on Wab09 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 1 yard to the WAB8 (Jared Lange;Joshua Gangloff). |
| Depauw | 2-G | on Wab08 | Spud Dick pass complete to Jeremiah Marks for 8 yards to the WAB0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:37. |
| | | Spud Dick pass attempt to Alex Koors good. |
| Wabash College 21, DePauw University 21 |
| | Drive: 15 plays, 83 yards, TOP 7:19 |
| | | Brendan Smith kickoff 52 yards to the WAB18, Gabe Guerrero return 12 yards to the WAB30 (Marc Hoeppner). |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab30 | WABASH COLLEGE drive start at 03:37. |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab30 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Brock Graham for 2 yards to the WAB32 (Tarren Collins). |
| Wab | 2-8 | on Wab32 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Mike Russell for 7 yards to the WAB39, out-of-bounds, QB hurry by Tarren Collins. |
| Wab | 3-1 | on Wab39 | Brock Graham rush for 2 yards to the WAB41, 1ST DOWN WAB (Kyle Monroe). |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Wab41 | Matt Hudson pass complete to Chad Sorenson for 19 yards to the DEPAUW40, 1ST DOWN WAB (Ryan McElwain). |
| Wab | 1-10 | on Depauw40 | C.P. Porter rush for 5 yards to the DEPAUW35 (J.J. Costello;Alex Fitch). |
| Wab | 2-5 | on Depauw35 | Matt Hudson pass incomplete, QB hurry by Ryan McElwain. |
| Wab | 3-5 | on Depauw35 | Timeout Wabash College, clock 01:33. |
| Wab | 3-5 | on Depauw35 | Matt Hudson pass incomplete to Mike Russell (Jevon Pruitt). |
| Wab | 4-5 | on Depauw35 | Matt Hudson pass intercepted by Jevon Pruitt at the DEPAUW4, Jevon Pruitt return 0 yards to the DEPAUW4. |
| | Drive: 8 plays, 35 yards, TOP 2:14 |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw04 | DEPAUW UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:23. |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw04 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 5 yards to the DEPAUW9 (Wes Anderson). |
| Depauw | 2-5 | on Depauw09 | Timeout Wabash College, clock 01:15. |
| Depauw | 2-5 | on Depauw09 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 4 yards to the DEPAUW13 (Jared Lange). |
| Depauw | 3-1 | on Depauw13 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 11 yards to the DEPAUW24, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Matt Kraft). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw24 | Spud Dick pass complete to Jeremiah Marks for no gain to the DEPAUW24 (Joshua Gangloff). |
| Depauw | 2-10 | on Depauw24 | Timeout DePauw University, clock 00:31. |
| Depauw | 2-10 | on Depauw24 | Jeremiah Marks rush for 14 yards to the DEPAUW38, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (A. Pynenberg;Rich Lehmann). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw38 | Timeout Wabash College, clock 00:20. |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Depauw38 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 19 yards to the WAB43, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW (Chad Peterman). |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Wab43 | Spud Dick pass complete to Bryan Mulligan for 6 yards to the WAB37 (Thomas Bell). |
| Depauw | 2-4 | on Wab37 | Spud Dick pass complete to Jeremiah Marks for 8 yards to the WAB29, 1ST DOWN DEPAUW, out-of-bounds. |
| Depauw | 1-10 | on Wab29 | Jord. Havercamp field goal attempt from 47 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| DePauw University 24, Wabash College 21 |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 67 yards, TOP 1:23 |
