| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | End of period [90:00]. |
| [89:56] | Shot by DPU Andy Morrison WIDE RIGHT. |
| [88:15] | Foul on Hiram College. |
| | Corner kick by HIRM Ty Smith [86:15]. |
| [85:45] | Foul on DePauw University Chris Schoenfeld against HIRM Brian Zilla. |
| [83:43] | Shot by HIRM Andy Harding, SAVE Tony Halterman. |
| [81:59] | Foul on DePauw University Matt Reda against HIRM Manolo Angel. |
| [79:57] | DPU substitution: George Elliott for Adrian Ables. |
| [79:02] | Shot by HIRM Ryan Greenhill, SAVE Tony Halterman. |
| [77:39] | Shot by HIRM Taylor Kiefer BLOCKED. |
| [77:28] | DPU substitution: Chris Schoenfeld for George Elliott. |
| [74:54] | Foul on DePauw University Andy Morrison against HIRM Brian Zilla. |
| [74:02] | Shot by DPU George Elliott WIDE LEFT. |
| [73:05] | DPU substitution: Matt Reda for Nate Snyder. |
| [73:05] | HIRM substitution: Josh Allman for Ryan Kramarz. |
| [71:57] | DPU substitution: Dean Weaver for David Large. |
| [71:57] | DPU substitution: Alieu Musa for Jon Krok. |
| [71:26] | Foul on DePauw University. |
| [70:12] | Foul on Hiram College Brian Zilla against DPU Nate Snyder. |
| | Corner kick by HIRM Ryan Greenhill [69:37]. |
| [67:37] | Shot by HIRM Brian Zilla, SAVE Tony Halterman. |
| | Corner kick by HIRM Ryan Greenhill [67:15]. |
| [66:13] | Foul on Hiram College Ryan Greenhill against DPU Adrian Ables. |
| [64:23] | Foul on Hiram College Manolo Angel against DPU Jon Krok. |
| [63:30] | HIRM substitution: Manolo Angel for Tanner Manfull. |
| [62:37] | DPU substitution: Jon Krok for Alieu Musa. |
| [61:40] | Shot by DPU Andy Morrison, SAVE Kirby Rice. |
| [61:01] | Shot by HIRM Ty Smith BLOCKED. |
| [60:05] | Foul on Hiram College Ryan Kramarz against DPU David Large. |
| [58:29] | Foul on DePauw University Louie Souza against HIRM Ryan Minick. |
| [56:02] | DPU substitution: David Large for Dean Weaver. |
| [57:43] | HIRM substitution: Tanner Manfull for Josh Allman. |
| [57:28] | Yellow card on HIRM Caleb Capron. |
| DePauw University 3, Hiram College 2 |
| [57:02] | DPU Andy Morrison PENALTY KICK GOAL, goal number 11 for season. |
| [57:02] | Foul on Hiram College Ryan Kramarz against DPU Adrian Ables. |
| [56:59] | Shot by DPU Andy Morrison HIT POST. |
| Hiram College 2, DePauw University 2 |
| [56:02] | GOAL by DPU Nate Snyder, Assist by Dean Weaver, goal number 8 for season. |
| [56:01] | Yellow card on DPU Nick Williams. |
| [55:11] | Header Shot by HIRM Daniel O'Callaghan, SAVE Tony Halterman. |
| | Corner kick by HIRM Ryan Greenhill [54:56]. |
| [51:42] | Shot by DPU Matt Schoenfeld WIDE RIGHT. |
| [50:42] | Header Shot by DPU Andy Morrison, SAVE Kirby Rice. |
| [49:55] | Foul on Hiram College Ryan Greenhill against DPU Matt Schoenfeld. |
| | Corner kick by DPU Adrian Ables [48:46]. |
| | For DPU: #1 Tony Halterman, #3 Adrian Ables, #5 Alieu Musa, #6 Nate Snyder, #8 George Elliott, #9 Andy Morrison, #10 Dean Weaver, #14 Matt Schoenfeld, #15 Louie Souza, #17 Andrew Desmarais, #22 Nick Williams. |
| | For HIRM: #2 Ryan Kramarz, #7 Ryan Greenhill, #18 Andy Harding, #22 Brian Zilla, #0 Kirby Rice, #5 Ryan Minick, #11 Ty Smith, #13 Taylor Kiefer, #3 Caleb Capron, #9 Daniel O'Callaghan, #15 Josh Allman. |
| | Start of 2nd period [45:00]. |