| 1933 Football Team | Team | 1995 |
| 1941 Men's Tennis Team | Team | 1999 |
| 1990 Men's Basketball Team | Team | 2003 |
| Glenn M. Adams '25 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1986 |
| J. Patrick Aikman '57 | Administration | 1998 |
| Joseph P. Allen IV '59 | Wrestling | 1994 |
| Dale D. Anderson '62 | Basketball (Men's) | 2002 |
| Norman Babcock '30 | Baseball | 1992 |
| Jennifer A. "Jenny" Bauer '88 | Basketball (Women's), Softball | 1999 |
| Emil J. Bavasi '38 | Baseball | 1989 |
| Mark W. Bills '23 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 2004 |
| Thomas P. Blake '61 | Cross Country (Men's), Swimming & Diving (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1993 |
| William V. Blake III '59 | Cross Country (Men's), Swimming & Diving (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1989 |
| Joy Rowe Blang '92 | Golf (Women's) | 2004 |
| Don M. Bollinger '36 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1991 |
| Richard J. Bonaccorsi '85 | Football | 2005 |
| Edwin C. Boswell '31 | Basketball (Men's), Golf (Men's) | 1996 |
| Robert G. Bottoms | Administration | 2005 |
| Robert A. Bradley '35 | Football, Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 1988 |
| Ann Wilhoite Brilley '68 | Golf (Women's) | 1991 |
| Thomas L. Brunkow '61 | Tennis (Men's) | 1996 |
| Arthur L. Bryant '56 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1989 |
| James G. Buelow Jr. '75 | Baseball, Football | 1997 |
| Dr. Jennifer Burns Pulido '90 | Tennis (Women's) | 2011 |
| James M. Callane '64 | Basketball (Men's) | 2002 |
| Dr. John M. Cassady '60 | Baseball | 2011 |
| Sam S. Chattin '63 | Football | 1998 |
| Harley G. "Skip" Collins '65 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 2009 |
| Charee Campbell Condict '98 | Swimming & Diving (Women's) | 2009 |
| Mary Washburn Conklin '28 | Track & Field (Women's) | 1986 |
| Dr. Thomas P. Cooper '66 | Baseball, Football | 1991 |
| Dr. George W. Crane '42 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Marion L. Crawley '30 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Coaching | 1986 |
| Willis Null "Bing" Davis '59 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1991 |
| Anthony J. de Nicola '86 | Baseball, Football | 2006 |
| Richard S. Dean '64 | Football | 1986 |
| Elizabeth Walse DeGraff '01 | Soccer (Women's) | 2012 |
| Terrence R. Dickey '92 | Football | 2010 |
| Robert P. Doolittle '29 | Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 1988 |
| Robert J. Doyle '82 | Football | 1999 |
| Chester C. Elson '36 | Football | 1988 |
| David B. Emens '61 | Cross Country (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1994 |
| Charles Erdmann | Coaching | 1986 |
| Philip N. Eskew '63 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1994 |
| George G. Eubank '33 | Basketball (Men's) | 1988 |
| C. Morgan Everson '66 | Basketball (Men's) | 2011 |
| Patrick M. Ewing '58 | Football | 2002 |
| Patricia K. Fehl '49 | Basketball (Women's), Field Hockey, Volleyball | 1994 |
| Richard R. Fillbrandt '43 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Tennis (Men's) | 1996 |
| Robert J. Fink '56 | Football, Coaching | 1990 |
| Susan Guldin Fischer '93 | Volleyball | 2012 |
| Walter R. Foltz '62 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1997 |
| Russell L. Freeland '51 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 1989 |
| Norman Frees '36 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1992 |
| Robert W. Fribley '35 | Football | 1986 |
| Ford C. Frick '15 | Baseball | 1989 |
| Dr. Carla C. Frtiz '95 | Soccer (Women's) | 2011 |
| Jay S. Frye '72 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 2001 |
| Ronald L. Galiene '58 | Football | 2003 |
| David M. Galle '87 | Basketball (Men's) | 2006 |
| Earl B. Gardner '48 | Basketball (Men's) | 1986 |
| Judith A. George | Coaching | 2005 |
| Robert P. Godwin '59 | Football, Wrestling | 1993 |
| Morris E. Goodnight '58 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 1990 |
| Helen Reynolds Gosnell | Administration | 1995 |
| Nancy J. Gritter '88 | Swimming & Diving (Women's) | 2000 |
| Dr. Bruce P. Grossnickle '74 | Golf (Men's) | 2005 |
| J. Kent Guild M.D. '53 | Basketball (Men's) | 2001 |
| Dr. Duff L. Gula '63 | Baseball, Football | 2003 |
| Cyrus L. Gunn '29 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1993 |
| Sandra L. Gyorgyi '84 | Tennis (Women's) | 2007 |
| Lee H. Hamilton '52 | Basketball (Men's) | 1987 |
| Midi Smyth Hansen '88 | Swimming & Diving (Women's) | 2000 |
| Robert R. Harvey | Coaching | 1990 |
| David S. Hathaway '84 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 2003 |
| Bradley D. Hauter '87 | Soccer (Men's) | 2004 |
| Heidi Shays Heinbaugh '91 | Field Hockey | 2003 |
| G. Richard Hershberger '57 | Cross Country (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1994 |
| Alan P. Hill '81 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1994 |
| Lewis R. Hirt '25 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 1990 |
| Jack M. Hogan '67 | Basketball (Men's) | 2003 |
| James A. Hollensteiner '53 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1998 |
| John P. Isenbarger '45 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1995 |
| Brian J. Jaworski '89 | Soccer (Men's) | 2002 |
| Donald W. Jones '43 | Basketball (Men's) | 1987 |
| Paul W. Jones '24 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Sam A. Juarascio '76 | Football | 2011 |
| Cloyd J. Julian '33 | Cross Country (Men's), Track & Field (Men's), Coaching | 1987 |
| Ted Katula | Coaching | 2000 |
| Kreg S. Kephart '77 | Football | 2007 |
| Robert C. Kirk '71 | Track & Field (Men's) | 2004 |
| Colleen Konicek '88 | Field Hockey | 2001 |
| Robert F. Kyle '78 | Baseball | 2005 |
| Gene C. Laker '54 | Basketball (Men's) | 2012 |
| Pete G. Land '90 | Soccer (Men's), Baseball | 2009 |
| Ellen Royse Lapierre '93 | Golf (Women's) | 2010 |
| Harold Laughlin '24 | Basketball (Men's) | 1992 |
| Robert B. Lee '35 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1987 |
| Robert D. Loring | Administration | 1997 |
| Eric V. Lortz '68 | Football | 2012 |
| George E. Lortz '34 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1986 |
| James C. Loveless '29 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1986 |
| Richard L. Mace '60 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1991 |
| J. Bruce Mackey '65 | Baseball, Football | 1993 |
| Lester B. Mathieson '57 | Football, Coaching | 1991 |
| Elmer E. McCall | Coaching | 1995 |
| Thomas L. McCormick '69 | Basketball (Men's) | 1994 |
| Thomas A. McGurk '68 | Basketball (Men's) | 2012 |
| Carl Meditch '59 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 2009 |
| Lloyd Messersmith '28 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 1986 |
| Edward H. Meyer Jr. '62 | Coaching | 2005 |
| Mary Louise Miller | Administration, Coaching | 1993 |
| Paul M. Mitchell '69 | Soccer (Men's), Tennis (Men's), Wrestling | 1995 |
| Dr. Donovan C. Moffett '22 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Track & Field (Men's), Coaching | 1986 |
| Rexford W. Moffett '32 | Basketball (Men's) | 1988 |
| Thomas A. Mont | Coaching | 1992 |
| Bruce M. Montgomerie '68 | Football | 2000 |
| Nick Mourouzis | Coaching | 2006 |
| Gregory T. Mutz '67 | Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 1986 |
| Ivan A. Myers '16 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Raymond R. Neal | Coaching | 1986 |
| Dr. John W. Oswald '38 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Dr. Steven S. Overman '72 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 2004 |
| Maclyn T. Parker '51 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 2007 |
| Richard E. Peeler '49 | Administration | 2000 |
| Charles W. Pence '18 | Football | 1987 |
| William A. Pendl '54 | Tennis (Men's) | 2010 |
| C. Wayne Perry '72 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 2010 |
| Earl Pierce '35 | Football | 1993 |
| Gordon T. Pittenger '73 | Basketball (Men's) | 2007 |
| Susan Bender Price '99 | Basketball (Women's) | 2010 |
| Dan Quayle '69 | Golf (Men's) | 2000 |
| Andrew J. Ramsay '30 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Dr. Adrienne Rasbach '94 | Swimming & Diving (Women's) | 2006 |
| J. Randall Reifers '68 | Golf (Men's) | 1997 |
| Guernsey Van Riper Jr. '30 | Baseball, Football | 1989 |
| Mark E. Rolfing '71 | Golf (Men's) | 1999 |
| Sally A. Rudicel M.D. '69 | Field Hockey | 2001 |
| Roland T. Rust '74 | Cross Country (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 2007 |
| Dr. Robert W. Schrier '57 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's) | 1986 |
| Richard E. Schulte '69 | Football | 1999 |
| Erwin E. Schulze '47 | Tennis (Men's) | 1999 |
| Gladys Scott | Administration | 1988 |
| Dr. Scott W. Shafer '70 | Cross Country (Men's) | 2011 |
| David A. Sheperd '51 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1996 |
| Barton A. Simpson '75 | Football | 1997 |
| Laurence F. Skelton '60 | Baseball | 2002 |
| M. Helen Smiley '60 | Administration, Coaching | 1995 |
| Paul C. Souder '41 | Tennis (Men's) | 1990 |
| Herbert J. Spier '62 | Basketball (Men's) | 1998 |
| Melissa Terrill Spowal '96 | Field Hockey | 2009 |
| Richard A. Strakowski '61 | Cross Country (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 2001 |
| Dr. Raymond F. Struck '26 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 1986 |
| Richard N. Sturtridge '27 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Dwight Tallman '59 | Basketball (Men's), Football | 1992 |
| Richard A. Tharp '70 | Basketball (Men's) | 1999 |
| George C. Thorton III '62 | Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 1996 |
| Richard P. Tinkham Jr. '54 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 2002 |
| Richard H. Tomey '60 | Baseball | 1994 |
| Robert R. Torkelson '82 | Football | 1999 |
| Jay C. True '81 | Football | 1997 |
| Fred C. Tucker '08 | Baseball, Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| Laurel H. Turk | Administration | 1995 |
| David L. Vear '53 | Football, Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 1996 |
| Alvin F. Volkman '34 | Basketball (Men's), Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1990 |
| Jeffrey T. Voris '89 | Football | 2009 |
| William Walton '47 | Basketball (Men's) | 1992 |
| John W. Ward '27 | Basketball (Men's) | 1986 |
| Dr. Carla J. Weaver '92 | Basketball (Women's), Volleyball | 2004 |
| Timothy A. Weaver '86 | Baseball, Football | 2007 |
| Randy R. Wells D.D.S. '77 | Baseball, Basketball (Men's), Football | 2001 |
| Phillip E. Wendel '86 | Basketball (Men's) | 2006 |
| Dr. Greg A. Werner '89 | Baseball, Football | 2006 |
| Charles A. West '49 | Basketball (Men's), Track & Field (Men's) | 1998 |
| Donald S. Wheaton '33 | Football | 1986 |
| Alisa Beth Shuck Wickliff '83 | Swimming & Diving (Women's) | 1997 |
| Kenneth A. Wieland Jr. '82 | Swimming & Diving (Men's) | 2005 |
| Peter B. Work '61 | Football, Track & Field (Men's), Wrestling | 2003 |
| Leonard H. Yorke '56 | Track & Field (Men's) | 1995 |
| Cecil E. Young '23 | Football, Track & Field (Men's) | 1986 |
| James P. Zerface '62 | Basketball (Men's) | 2006 |