2009 NCAA® Division III Softball Championship
Greencastle, Indiana First Round

Ohio Northern University: First Round Champions (photo: Alex Turco)
| Thursday, May 7 |
| Game 1 |
#5 Defiance (28-14) vs. #4 Trine (29-10) |
Defiance, 1-0 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 2 |
#3 Adrian (34-6) vs. #6 Thomas More (34-9) |
Thomas More, 4-3 (10) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 3 |
#7 Hiram (26-14) vs. #2 DePauw (28-7) |
DePauw, 2-1 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 4 |
#1 Ohio Northern (35-3) vs. #4 Trine (29-11) |
Ohio Northern, 4-3 (9) Trine eliminated |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Friday, May 8 |
| Game 5: |
#3 Adrian (34-7) vs. #7 Hiram (26-15) |
Hiram, 2-1 (Adrian eliminated) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 6 |
#6 Thomas More (35-9) vs. #2 DePauw (29-7) |
DePauw, 2-0 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 7 |
#1 Ohio Northern (36-3) vs. #5 Defiance (29-14) |
Ohio Northern, 8-5 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Saturday, May 9 |
|
| Game 8 |
#6 Thomas More (35-10) vs. #7 Hiram (27-15) |
Thomas More, 13-11 (10) (Hiram eliminated) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 9 |
#2 DePauw (30-7) vs. #1 Ohio Northern (37-3) |
Ohio Northern, 5-3 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 10 |
#6 Thomas More (36-10) vs. #5 Defiance (29-15) |
Defiance, 8-2 (Thomas More eliminated) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 11 |
#5 Defiance (30-15) vs. #2 DePauw (30-8) |
DePauw, 7-0 (Defiance eliminated) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Sunday, May 10 |
| Game 12 |
#1 Ohio Northern (38-3) vs. #2 DePauw (31-8) |
DePauw, 4-0 |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |
| Game 13 |
#1 Ohio Northern (38-4) vs. #2 DePauw (32-8) |
Ohio Northern, 4-1 (DePauw eliminated) |
BOX SCORE |
RECAP |